Choosing Between Lock Replacement and Lock Rekeying

Lock Replacement

Have you ever had a chill down your neck at the thought of someone else having the key to your home? Your house deserves top-notch security, and high-quality locks are the primary barrier to protection. But when dealing with a faulty lock, the question arises: replace or rekey? We won’t just select sides here; we’ll assist you in choosing the best option. We’ll check the advantages and disadvantages of each approach, considering cost, security efficiency, and your situation. Remember, protecting your home is not an option; it’s a must. So, let us identify the approach that best ensures your peace of mind and the protection of your loved ones. 

Understanding Replacement of Locks 

Lock replacement involves disassembling the present lock mechanism and replacing it with a new one. This method may involve replacing all the hardware, including the lock cylinder, latch, and strike plate. It gives a new start for your security system. 


  • Upgrading to a new lock can increase overall security. 
  • It enables the option of advanced or customized lock mechanisms 
  • Ideal for addressing worries about lost or compromised keys. 


  • It is typically more costly than rekeying. 
  • Takes longer than rekeying
  • Doors and frames may need to be adjusted. 

Replacement of the lock becomes the solution in several conditions. In some cases, security upgrades are necessary to enhance security measures. Furthermore, in the case of a key compromise, such as losing keys or experiencing an invasion of privacy, selecting a replacement provides a complete solution. A replacement is also the best option when there is a change in property ownership; this ensures that no prior keys can be used to access the property. 

Exploring Rekeying of Locks 

Lock rekeying is modifying the internal configuration of a lock cylinder to render existing keys unusable. The locksmith changes the pins within the lock to fit a new key, leaving the old ones worthless. It works without replacing the complete lock mechanism, resulting in an affordable alternative.  


  • It is less expensive than lock replacement. 
  • Faster than installing a new lock. 
  • There is no need to change the complete lock mechanism. 


  • It may not offer advanced security features. 
  • The lock itself stays unchanged, therefore wear and tear are not addressed. 
  • Previous keys could still be in circulation. 

Rekeying a lock is the preferred option in certain cases. Cost concerns and budget limits play an important part in decision-making. It is beneficial during tenant changes since it allows for new key issuance without replacing the complete lock, making it an economical option. Furthermore, rekeying the lock is appropriate in situations where only a simple security upgrade is necessary, resolving minor security problems without the need for a complete replacement. 

Also Read: Can a Locksmith Rekey a Car Door Lock? 

Guiding Decisions between Replacement and Rekeying 

Real-life situations and instances help to illustrate how to choose between lock replacement and lock rekeying. For example, if keys are lost, the choice may be based on security concerns. If it is crucial, replacement of the lock may be preferable, although rekeying may be acceptable for low risk. Similarly, in a change of ownership, the uncertainty of prior keys may lead to a replacement for a comprehensive security repair. Rekeying might be a more cost-effective alternative if the old lock is considered secure.  

When deciding whether to update your lock or get a new key, the best advice comes from the locksmith experts. They are well-versed in security and can advise you on what is best for your situation. Locksmiths assess factors like cost, security, and convenience. Talking to them offers access to their expertise, allowing you to make smart choices appropriate for your situation. So, when it comes to keeping your home safe, rely on the professionals who work with locks every day – locksmiths are the real key to a better and more secure future. 

Navigate Security Choices with a Trustworthy Locksmith 

When deciding between replacement and rekeying, keep in mind that experienced specialists hold the key to a safe future. If you’re looking for a reliable locksmith with experience and dedication to your security, call Spot On Locksmith. Our team knows the complexities of safeguarding your area and can advise you on the best option for your requirements. Trust Spot on Locksmith to be your partner in creating a safe and secure atmosphere. 

Scroll to Top